When word broke on May 2nd that an elite team of US Navy commandos had finally caught up to al-Qaida terrorist leader Osama bin Laden in the Pakistani town of Abbottabad, relieved Americans erupted in spontaneous celebrations. Israelis were thrilled as well, but could not show it at the time, as the news came on Yom Hashoah – the annual day for remembering the six million Jewish victims of the Holocaust.
By custom, it is a solemn occasion. There’s no “entertainment” on television. No bars, restaurants or dance halls are open. Radio stations switch for the day to classical music.
Yet the subdued Israeli reaction also stems from their own bitter experience with such targeted killings of terror chieftains. They know that taking out the head may be a setback to terrorist organizations, but they always seem to spring back and sometimes under even more militant leaders.
More bark than bite
Israel’s history with bin Laden and his al-Qaida network is one of being a prime target of its ideological rage but having a lower priority in terms of its actual operations.
“Israel, as part of the Judeo-Crusader front, remained a very high target mostly in the field of propaganda, through the Internet, but not in fact,” Dr. Reuven Paz, an Israeli expert on Islamist movements, told The Christian Edition in the wake of bin Laden’s death.
“In the past decade, the threat to Israel inside its borders was quite low, and was mostly from very small jihadist groups in Gaza,” Paz explained. “They launched mortars and missiles over the borders, with or without the approval of Hamas. But attacks inside Israel were low in the list of priorities of the global Jihad, following good [Israeli] security measures and operational difficulties, in addition to the low support for al-Qaida among the Palestinians and their preference of supporting Hamas and Hizballah.”
In contrast, Paz noted, there was a greater threat to Israeli and Jewish interests abroad, including an attack against an Israeli civilian airliner over Mombasa, Kenya in November 2002 and a simultaneous assault against an Israeli-owned hotel there. Other attacks against Jewish targets included the bombing of an historic synagogue in Djerba, Tunisia, and the targeting of popular Jewish sites in Morocco and a synagogue in Istanbul in 2003, stated Paz, an associate of the Interdisciplinary Center in Herzliya.
Nevertheless, Israel has been heavily involved in the fight against al-Qaida and its affiliated jihadist groups for decades.
Contact with the enemy
According to Israeli journalist Ronen Bergman, it was the Mossad which first identified the growing global threat of the terrorist network in 1995, after the CIA and Egyptian intelligence came up empty while investigating an attempted hit on President Hosni Mubarak during his visit to Ethiopia that year. After receiving a joint request for help, Israeli intelligence traced the operation back to a group called “the Base” in English and led by a wealthy Saudi businessman turned Muslim holy warrior.
The Mossad was also the first to attempt, unsuccessfully, to assassinate bin Laden: In 1995, it recruited his secretary to poison him, claims Bergman.
In his classic book “Gideon’s Spies: the Secret History of the Mossad,” award-winning author Gordon Thomas also revealed that Israeli intelligence agents have been going toe-to-toe with al-Qaida operatives since the 1990s in dozens of countries around the world, quietly eliminating scores of terrorists who might otherwise have threatened not only Israel but the entire world.
In addition, Israeli-born security analyst Yossef Bodansky was one of the earliest to publicly sound the alarm about al-Qaida and other Salafi jihadist groups in his writings and work as a counterterrorism adviser inside the US Congress. His book “Bin Laden: The Man Who Declared War on America” was one of the first comprehensive exposes on al-Qaida, its deep ties to Pakistani intelligence, and its growing worldwide network of operatives trained in the group’s camps in Afghanistan and Pakistan. If anyone forewarned of planes being plowed into skyscrapers, it was Bodansky.
American fixation
After bin Laden’s volunteer mujahadeen helped drive the Soviets out of Afghanistan in the late 1980s, he shifted his base to Sudan and his focus to jihad against the West.
The 1991 Gulf War would channel that focus against President George Bush and Washington’s close relations with the Arab oil powers. From 1996 onwards, bin Laden rallied his troops around the primary goal of purging American soldiers from the holy soil of his native Saudi Arabia. In his 1998 fatwa declaring war on “Crusaders and Jews,” Palestine was mentioned only third, again after the American infidel presence in Saudi Arabia and UN sanctions on Iraq.
Only more recently did bin Laden assert that Palestine was “my nation’s pivotal issue.” It was, he declared, “an important factor in giving me since childhood… an overwhelming feeling that we must stand by the oppressed and punish the unjust Jews and their backers.”
This homage to the Palestinian cause may be a bit late and overstated, and more a product of al-Qaida setbacks on other fronts. But bin Laden’s followers have made a number of attempts to target Israel, while persistently railing against the Zionist enemy in order to raise funds and recruit operatives.
Border brushes
The most serious al-Qaida campaign against Israel was orchestrated by “al-Qaida Mesopotamia” – led by Abu Musab al-Zarqawi. Known for its bloody operations against American forces in Iraq, the group also sought to establish operational footholds close to Israel’s borders.
The most dramatic sign of this was a barrage of Katyusha rockets fired from southern Lebanon in December 2005 which struck northern Israel. A videotape broadcast days later declared that the bombardment of “the sons of apes and pigs” was just a small sample of what bin Laden had in store for them.
Just weeks earlier, al-Zarqawi’s network also attacked three luxury hotels in Amman, killing dozens of civilians. The operation aimed to target Israeli and Western tourists in hotels the group claimed were “dens of Zionist spies.” At the time, militant Islamic websites warned: “After the attack in the heart of Jordan, it will soon be possible to reach Jewish targets in Israel.”
Had they succeeded, the most spectacular al-Qaida attacks against Israel would have been an operation targeting the landmark Azrieli Towers in Tel Aviv and a plot to steal a Saudi Air Force F-15 for a suicide run on an Eilat hotel. Several other large scale attacks on Israel by terror cells affiliated with al-Qaida have reportedly been thwarted, but smaller attacks have succeeded. The list of strikes and averted operations includes:
October 2004 – Al-Qaida elements infiltrated Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula and targeted Israeli tourists at Taba and other resorts.
July 2005 – Al-Qaida linked terrorists bombed a hotel in the Egyptian report of Sharm el-Sheikh in a bid to kill Israeli and Western tourists.
August 2005 – An al-Qaida cell fired Katyusha rockets from the hills above Aqaba into the neighboring Israeli port city of Eilat.
November 2005 – Al-Qaida suicide bombers struck three Jordanian luxury hotels in Amman, killing 60 persons.
December 2005 – An ‘al-Qaida in Iraq’ cell operating in southern Lebanon launched 10 rockets into northern Israel, wounding three people.
March 2006 – Two Palestinians from the West Bank were indicted on charges of belonging to al-Qaida and receiving funds to carry out a double bombing in Jerusalem.
June 2006 – The Army of Islam, an al-Qaida affiliate operating in Gaza, was among the three Palestinian militias involved in the cross-border abduction of IDF soldier Gilad Schalit.
January 2008 – Mohammed Najem, an Israeli Arab from Nazareth who was studying in Jerusalem, solicited al-Qaida help to shoot down George W. Bush’s helicopter during the US president’s visit to Israel.
July 2008 – The Shin Bet security agency announced the arrest of two Bedouins from the Negev who were in contact with al-Qaida in hopes of planning mass terror strikes in Israel, including against the 49-storey Azrieli Towers, perhaps using a hijacked plane. Other potential targets were Ben-Gurion Airport and IDF bases.
February 2009 – An al-Qaida linked cell claimed to have fired mortars into Israel from Gaza.
April 2010 – Rockets fired by an al-Qaida cell from the Sinai Peninsula target Israel’s southern resort city of Eilat. Two of the three rockets landed in neighboring Aqaba, Jordan.
June 2010 – Israel arrested a three-man cell from Jenin accused of murdering an Israeli taxi driver, planning to attack Christian pilgrims and attempting to travel to an al-Qaida training camp in Somalia.
July 2010 – A nine-man terror cell was uncovered in Nazareth with an arsenal of weapons and plans to murder IDF soldiers and slit the throat of visiting Pope Benedict XVI, all in the name of al-Qaida.
November 2010 – A group with avowed al-Qaida links issued a threat – for the first time in Hebrew – to avenge Israel’s killing of two Gaza terrorists who had planned to attack Israelis in the Egyptian Sinai.
Summer 2010 to Spring 2011 – Numerous rocket and mortar barrages were fired into Israel from the Gaza Strip by al-Qaida affiliated groups, some of which included gunman who had fought coalition troops in Iraq and Afghanistan and been smuggled into the Strip without the knowledge or permission of Hamas.
Haranguing Hamas
With the Middle East now in such chaos, the Israeli assessment is that al-Qaida elements will increase their efforts to strike at the Israeli heartland in the years to come. But the network’s estranged relations with Hamas also bear watching for its own reasons.
In fact, Salafist groups in Gaza have posed a growing challenge to the right flank of Hamas for several years now, criticizing the Sunni Islamist group for cooperating with Shi’ite Iran and its Lebanese proxy Hizbullah. They have also criticized Hamas for being too narrowly focused on the Palestinian struggle and not on the global fight for Islam, a charge they have also leveled at Hamas’s parent organization, the Muslim Brotherhood.
While al-Qaida preaches “jihad now” to achieve a worldwide caliphate without borders, the Muslim Brotherhood has taken a more long-term strategy to achieve the same goal, even participating in democratic elections in various Arab countries as a means to gradually accumulate power.
So after berating Hamas for forging ties to Iran, al-Qaida then blasted the rival Islamist terror militia for taking part in the 2006 Palestinian elections. Ever since, al-Qaida has repeatedly skewered Hamas over other perceived compromises, including its decision to invoke a “calm” with Israel following Operation Cast Lead.
On 14 August 2009, the criticism went beyond mere rhetoric when the leader of a small group of gunman from the Ansar Jund Allah militia took over a mosque in Rafah, in southern Gaza, and declared an independent Islamic state in Gaza to be ruled by strict shari’a law. The radical cleric also declared the Hamas civil authority in Gaza to be null and void, ordering all “true Muslims” to follow him instead.
Hamas responded by sending hundreds of militiamen, backed up by heavy weapons, against the mosque, killing the rebel leader and 23 of his followers. The incident cost Hamas support on both flanks, as moderate Arabs and Western sympathizers were shocked by the blunt use of force against fellow Muslims, while conservative Sunnis began peeling off to more radical groups.
Ever since then, Israeli security agencies have noticed a steady trickle of Hamas gunman joining Salafist groups in Gaza. The Salafist camp has also been swelled by recruits from Palestinian Islamic Jihad and other splinter groups disillusioned with the truce with Israel, as well as the “sharia-lite” social order currently prevailing in the Gaza Strip.
This might explain why Hamas rushed to condemn the US for killing bin Laden, in hopes of drawing back disaffected Palestinian Muslims.
With bin Laden dead, Israeli intelligence is concerned that such targeted killings, as often as not, reshuffle the deck in undesirable ways. The elimination of an organization’s leader tends to paralyze the group in the short term, but it sometimes results in the rise of an even more dangerous successor.
Ironically, Israel’s targeting of Hamas leader Sheikh Ahmed Yassin, a devout Sunni vehemently opposed to partnering with Iran, made way for the ascent of Khaled Mashaal, who had no such qualms and has used the ties with Tehran to bolster his group’s firepower to unprecedented levels.
With contributions by Yaakov Katz and Florence Bache. This article first appeared in the June 2011 issue of The Jerusalem Post Christian Edition, published in partnership with the International Christian Embassy Jerusalem; www.jpost.com/ce